Teachers banned after 'unacceptable' misconduct at school in Horncastle

A number of teachers have been banned from the profession after allegations of unacceptable practices at a special school in Lincolnshire were found proved.

Head teacher Adam Webb, deputy head Alison Simmons, tutor Thomas Hayward, and tutor Matthew Oyitch all worked for the Build-a-Future Independent School, which, at the time of the allegations, had sites in West Ashby, near Horncastle, and Hubbert’s Bridge, near Boston.

But now prohibition orders have been issued against the foursome by the Government’s Teaching Regulation Agency (TRA) after independent misconduct panels, held in public, unearthed a number of safeguarding failures in their work.

Mr Webb, 44, and Ms Simmons, 56, are not entitled to apply to teach again, while Mr Hayward, 39, cannot apply for the ban to lifted until 2034 at the earliest, and 2031 for Mr Oyitch, 31.

The Build-a-Future Independent School at West Ashby, Horncastle. (PHOTO BY: Google Maps)placeholder image
The Build-a-Future Independent School at West Ashby, Horncastle. (PHOTO BY: Google Maps)

The private Build-A-Future School had a capacity for 125 children, aged 13 to 16, who had been permanently excluded from mainstream schools or have special educational needs or disabilities (SEND) or have mental-health issues.

The group were arrested by police in January 2021 on suspicion of child cruelty or neglect after a number of allegations were made against them by an anonymous whistleblower.

Although the police investigation ended with no further action taken, the matter continued to be monitored by the teaching authorities, and was referred to the TRA in 2022.

The TRA’s misconduct panels convened in January, and the body has now published full and final prohibition-order reports on all four teachers.

The Teaching Regulation Agency has issued prohibition orders against the three teachers.placeholder image
The Teaching Regulation Agency has issued prohibition orders against the three teachers.

Mr Webb’s report says he did not attend his eight-day hearing and was not legally represented. But the panel ruled that his conduct was “entirely unacceptable” and “likely to bring the teaching profession into disrepute”.

He was found to have thrown eggs and stones at or near pupils, encouraged playfighting and used derogatory, demeaning or offensive language towards vulnerable children.

He was also accused of encouraging pupils to use a dead animal as a ball, allowing aerosols to be thrown onto a bonfire, and shouting and swearing at staff.

Mr Webb, who was appointed head in 2017, submitted a statement outlining his dedication to the school and insisting that many pupils made good progress while he was in charge.

However, the panel found that his misconduct “was not an isolated lapse but formed a sustained course of conduct over several months”.

Mr Webb had “failed to safeguard the welfare of pupils” at the school and had, in some cases, “reinforced harmful behaviour and attitudes”.

The panel also found that he had “crossed a clear safeguarding threshold” and had exposed some pupils to “inappropriate and harmful experiences”.

Ms Simmons, who started work at Build-A-Future in 2017, also did not attend her misconduct hearing and was not legally represented.

In a statement, she denied the allegations, and character references described her as a “kind and supportive” deputy head.

But the panel found all but one of the allegations proved. She had shown “no insight or remorse” and her behaviour had “amounted to unprofessional conduct, exposing children to risk”.

It was found that Ms Simmons took eggs on a school trip to Woodhall Spa to be thrown at pupils, failed to prevent staff using sexualised and derogatory language at pupils and took no action when witnessing inappropriate behaviour by another staff member.

“Her conduct fell far below what is expected of a teacher, both in relation to the emotional and physical safety of pupils,” the panel concluded.

She had failed in her duty as the school’s designated safeguarding lead, and had also been dishonest by lying “to prevent the identification of wrongdoing”.

Mr Hayward, who started work at the school in 2018, did not attend his misconduct hearing and was not legally represented.

He denied the allegations against him, and it was noted that he had been “very accommodating” during the police stage of the investigation.

The panel found that he allowed playfighting among pupils and even participated in it, and engaged in inappropriate behaviour that included laying on top of a pupil and simulating having sex with them.

He also threw stones, and allowed others to throw stones, at pupils, encouraged pupils to use a dead animal as a ball, and encouraged pupils to go up on a cherry-picker without a safety harness.

It was also found that Mr Hayward threw, and allowed others to throw, aerosols on to a bonfire, threw eggs at or near pupils, put stones down pupils’ trousers, used insulting language against pupils and made racist comments and jokes.

He also said he was going to encourage pupils to bully each other and, on one occasion, it was found that he attended school with boxes of live ammunition and bullets in his car.

"The panel considered that his maturity and experience should have led him to appreciate more fully that his actions were serious misconduct,” said the report into his behaviour.

Mr Oyitch was also not present or represented.

He commenced employment as a tutor at the school in October 2018.

In a statement, he said he has 'always considered himself a good person’ and ‘stressed that such allegations were not in his nature’.

“He wrote that during his time at the school, he always tried to go above and beyond for learners,” the report said.

“He stated that although he denies the allegations, he recognised that some aspects of the school environment could be misconstrued as wrong-doing when judged against mainstream educational standards,” the report said. “Because of the nature of the school and the complexity of learners’ needs, staff had to adopt a multi-faceted approach, including needs‑based support, empathy, patience, and, critically, humour.”

The report would go to to conclude: “In this case, the panel has found some of the allegations proven and found that those proven facts amount to unacceptable professional conduct and/or conduct that may bring the profession into disrepute.”

All teachers have a right to appeal to the High Court.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice