The Top 20 Oak Island discoveries helping to unravel the 200 year-old mystery

Here we list the top 20 discoveries made to date which provide clues that may help to solve the Oak Island mystery. If viewing on a desktop: hover over each photo for the full description.

For over 200 years, people have been searching for treasure on Oak Island, centering around a mysterious 230ft-deep booby-trapped shaft known as the ‘money pit’. This floods when excavations reach a certain depth. Situated off the coast of Nova Scotia, Canada, the island and its long-held secret are now the subject of a popular History Channel show The Curse of Oak Island. Several important artefacts have been unearthed during the six seasons of the show - both on and off the island. A number of these were discovered by Lincolnshire metal detection expert Gary Drayton. Join us as we look back through the years, decades and centuries to uncover the 20 most significant finds to date - which may just help to solve the mystery once and for all.

Here is our Top 20 list of the most important Oak Island discoveries to date.placeholder image
Here is our Top 20 list of the most important Oak Island discoveries to date.
The discovery that started it all - the money pit was originally discovered in 1795 when three young boys visiting the island noticed a circular depression in the ground. They dug down thinking they would discover pirate treasure. Subsequent excavations revealed layers of oak platforms, the 90ft stone and Chappell Vault. Its depth of around 200ft suggests something of high importance or value was placed here. The exact location of the original pit has yet to be found after it was lost when previous excavation work disrupted the surface or the area.placeholder image
The discovery that started it all - the money pit was originally discovered in 1795 when three young boys visiting the island noticed a circular depression in the ground. They dug down thinking they would discover pirate treasure. Subsequent excavations revealed layers of oak platforms, the 90ft stone and Chappell Vault. Its depth of around 200ft suggests something of high importance or value was placed here. The exact location of the original pit has yet to be found after it was lost when previous excavation work disrupted the surface or the area.
The 90ft stone - Found in the money pit during the first organised excavation in 1803, the stone slab featured bizarre symbols carved into it. No-one has definitively been able to decipher the code, although one attempt by Rev A. T. Kempton in 1949 suggests it can be translated to read: Forty feet below two million pounds are buried.placeholder image
The 90ft stone - Found in the money pit during the first organised excavation in 1803, the stone slab featured bizarre symbols carved into it. No-one has definitively been able to decipher the code, although one attempt by Rev A. T. Kempton in 1949 suggests it can be translated to read: Forty feet below two million pounds are buried.
Pulled out of borehole H8 in the money pit area during current excavations by the Laginas team. The bones have been examined and found to come from two people - someone of European origin and another of Middle Eastern origin.placeholder image
Pulled out of borehole H8 in the money pit area during current excavations by the Laginas team. The bones have been examined and found to come from two people - someone of European origin and another of Middle Eastern origin.
One of Gary Draytons greatest Oak Island finds, the lead cross, found at Smiths Cove, has been analysed by a scientist to originate from Europe during the time of the Knights Templar. Confirmed Templar coins have also been found by Drayton and others. On the show, Rick Lagina noticed its striking similarity to a Templar prison carving (see below).placeholder image
One of Gary Draytons greatest Oak Island finds, the lead cross, found at Smiths Cove, has been analysed by a scientist to originate from Europe during the time of the Knights Templar. Confirmed Templar coins have also been found by Drayton and others. On the show, Rick Lagina noticed its striking similarity to a Templar prison carving (see below).
Members of the Laginas team visited Domme Castle in France where they were shown a carving in a dungeon where many Templars were imprisoned in the early 1300s. Images of figures on the cross bear a striking resemblance to the lead cross found on Oak Island.placeholder image
Members of the Laginas team visited Domme Castle in France where they were shown a carving in a dungeon where many Templars were imprisoned in the early 1300s. Images of figures on the cross bear a striking resemblance to the lead cross found on Oak Island.
An old drawing of an alleged 1347 map presented on the show by the late researcher Zena Halpern. The map depicts Oak Island and writings in old French - a type of slang used between the 8th and 14th centuries. Some of the points of the map have been translated to read the hatch, the valve and the vault in the base of the earth. Interestingly, one pointing to the money pit area is said to read the oak, enter here.placeholder image
An old drawing of an alleged 1347 map presented on the show by the late researcher Zena Halpern. The map depicts Oak Island and writings in old French - a type of slang used between the 8th and 14th centuries. Some of the points of the map have been translated to read the hatch, the valve and the vault in the base of the earth. Interestingly, one pointing to the money pit area is said to read the oak, enter here.
The stone was discovered at the islands Joudreys Cove by locals some time ago. Noticing strange carvings on it, they blew it up, believing the treasure lay buried beneath. Treasure hunter Gilbert Hedden recovered fragments of it in 1936, one of which had Rune symbols similar to the letters H+O. It is not known what the original carving said when the huge rock was in one piece.placeholder image
The stone was discovered at the islands Joudreys Cove by locals some time ago. Noticing strange carvings on it, they blew it up, believing the treasure lay buried beneath. Treasure hunter Gilbert Hedden recovered fragments of it in 1936, one of which had Rune symbols similar to the letters H+O. It is not known what the original carving said when the huge rock was in one piece.
Unearthed by metal detection expert Gary Drayton along the islands south-west shore, the object, a tip of a spear, has been identified as Roman by an antiquities expert who says it could be as much as 2,000 years-old.placeholder image
Unearthed by metal detection expert Gary Drayton along the islands south-west shore, the object, a tip of a spear, has been identified as Roman by an antiquities expert who says it could be as much as 2,000 years-old.
The alleged vault was discovered by William Chappell in 1897 when a drill passed through a layer of concrete-like material and wood at a depth of 153ft and came back with fragments of gold chain and parchment paper. This suggested the team had penetrated a man-made chamber containing treasure. Pictured is the site of the dig by William Chappell and Frederick Blair in 1897.placeholder image
The alleged vault was discovered by William Chappell in 1897 when a drill passed through a layer of concrete-like material and wood at a depth of 153ft and came back with fragments of gold chain and parchment paper. This suggested the team had penetrated a man-made chamber containing treasure. Pictured is the site of the dig by William Chappell and Frederick Blair in 1897.
Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice