Farmer reflects on the history of agricultural red tape

Rotarian Mark Strawson entertained and educated his Rotarian colleagues at lunch last week with a talk about his choice of career and the intricacies he now finds himself faced with as a farmer.

Calculations used to be carried out based on area measured in acres. And most farmers still use this measure, even though all paperwork is now in metric (Hectares). 2.5acres = 1 Hectare, or roughly the size of a football pitch.

Farming news.placeholder image
Farming news.

When the country went metric and machinery became more sophisticated and accurate, area measurements needed to be made to 0.1m accuracy. When Set-aside came into being in the 1990’s it was necessary to increase the level of accuracy to 0.01m. Mark said they now have to increase the accuracy to the nearest millimetre.

Therefore it is necessary to measure the centre of a field boundary hedge to the nearest 1mm. Given that any hedge can be anything from two to 10 or more metres wide, Mark considered measuring the centre to nearest mm is going to be fun - complete with scratches!

Mark said he graduated from University some 50 years ago, and in this time, inflation has increased prices by tenfold. However, he said the price of wheat 50 years ago was about £50 per tonne. It is now sold for £180 per tonne - less than it was during the great depression in the 1920’s and 1930’s.

In 1975 the price of farmland was around £1,000 per acre but has increased in line with inflation and today is about £10,000 per acre. During this period the world population has gone from 4 to 8 billion. Mark said improvements in farming techniques, better equipment, better pesticides, better application of fertilizers and genetic improvement in crops have all combined to allow more food to be produced per unit area so that today we produce much more food on less land area than we used in the past.

The average financial return on farmland today is around two per cent, he said. Some will be doing better than this, but many will be much worse, especially on some small stock farms in the hills. With the drought this year many farmers have worked hard all year and made a loss. Many farmers will have worked for years for less than the minimum wage, he revealed.

There has been much talk recently about Inheritance Tax (IT) on farms and small businesses. The Government originally brought in agricultural property relief on farmland to encourage businesses to invest in long-term assets, such as buildings and land drainage. As the value of farmland increased, farmers became vulnerable also to Capital Gains Tax.

Mark explained that if a farmer gives away his assets to the next generation during his lifetime they must pay a full market rent for those assets. If a farmer gives away his farm, he would then have to pay the full market rent which would leave him with very little to live on. If the farmer lives for more than seven years after giving away his assets, then there would be no inheritance tax, but is where the uncertainty lies. If you give it away too soon then you will be left with nothing to live on, but if you don’t live for seven years then there will be inheritance tax to pay. He said the whole issue is a difficult dilemma and this has preoccupied farmers for the last few months - since the new policy was announced by Government.

Mark accepted the government has just announced that the threshold for paying inheritance tax has been raised from £1m to £2.5m for the farmer and spouse – so £5m for a farm couple. This has been a great relief for many. Mark also pointed out that a recent survey reported that over 40 per cent of UK farmers were single so these would just be eligible for the £2.5m relief, but in most cases this should be sufficient. Mark was also surprised that this policy seemed only to have stirred the farming community even though it also applies to any business via the Business Property Relief policy. But he suggested perhaps farming is more affected by the extremely high capital value of farmland.

Mark explained the thinking of the price support mechanism introduced by the EEC – Intervention. This worked to maintain price by purchasing crops when the price was falling (in a good year with high yields) and then selling it off later when the price had risen (after a poor harvest resulting in smaller yields). A buy cheap and sell cheap policy that seemed to work until there was a succession of good productive years resulting in low prices triggering the Intervention purchasing of vast tonnage of cereals. In reality, this vast tonnage only represented a few days’ supply for the whole of Europe, but it nevertheless triggered a great deal of comment about wine lakes, butter mountains, etc.

Politically this was an issue that eventually resulted in an initiative called Set aside - requiring the farmer to set aside from production 15 per cent of his land. This resulted in a drop in production but different crops had slightly different rules making the whole policy very complex and expensive for the Government to manage, recalled Mark. The policy lasted for around 20 years, by which time it was working reasonably well but it was decided that a new simpler system of support should be introduced – Single Farm Payment - which was based on the total farm area. This meant that large farms and farmers got a much larger payment than smaller, less efficient farms. This also caused more political pressure, and, after Brexit, there are farms subsidised with public money if they provide 'Public Good' such as wildflower meadows, but no support to produce food.

Looking to renewables Mark accepted there were clear financial benefits to the farmer for having solar farms - the income was much more secure and reliable compared to the profit that can be gained from a food crop which is subject to International Market performance.

Mark was thanked for his stimulating presentation of farming life which had sparked an interest with the assembled members.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice